Unrwa, Biden and Gaza: is cruelty the point?
JVL Introduction
Like almost every reader of this website I imagine, in a choice between Trump and Biden, we would, with a hugely reluctant sigh vote Biden.
So, too, Peter Beinart. But he is clearly troubled: “I have to admit that I see a certain amount of evil in the policies of the administration that we’re being asked to see as the good guy in this domestic narrative.”
Not surprisingly it is Gaza that troubles him. Or rather, Biden. Following the ICJ judgment the Biden administration’s decision to suspend US funding for UNRWA is pretty unfathomable.
“I don’t know if cruelty is the point of this policy by the Biden administration, but cruelty is very, very deeply, very profoundly the effect.”
RK
This article was originally published by the Beinart Notebook on Mon 29 Jan 2024. Read the original here.
Biden and Gaza: is cruelty the point?
Loading article text…
There is much to admire about Peter Beinart but he is not a socialist. He still thinks in terms of good and bad guys. And for him, however they wobble, the Democrats are the good guys.
There is no contextualisation of what is happening with regard to Gaza. Such as the fact that Biden stole half of Afghanistan’s foreign reserves outright and refused to allow their government access to the rest .
Of the fact that Obama’s concessions towards Cuba that Trump reversed have been kept.
Biden is nothing if not a US imperialist. There isn’t a war that he has’t advocated. The Democrats are never happier than when in a war.
Holding your nose and voting for Biden is not a serious option for those who wish to change and challenge US imperialism.
This is a really thoughtful and clear article
Why would anyone support another who is complicit in genocide?
Peter Beinart may still decide to vote for Genocide Joe, despite his misgivings. But I suspect that a lot of people will not. I think that they will have made the correct choice.
It must be noted that one of Israel’s weapons is to lie. This means delays in helping Palestinians until the Israeli claims are proved to be false. Hence progression of Israel’s destruction of Palestinians.
With thanks to Wikipedia, ‘In part IV of his Ethics, Spinoza states the following maxim: Proposition 65: “According to the guidance of reason, of two things which are good, we shall follow the greater good, and of two evils, follow the less”.’
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lesser_of_two_evils_principle
As a dual citizen of the US and UK, I can say I am sure that most supporters of the US Democratic Party over the decades since 1945 are probably feeling much the same way as Peter Beinart (and me). My reaction is very different from his, however — so far anyway — is that in spite of Trump, who must somehow be stopped from running at all, I cannot and will not support a man who has chosen to support genocide in the face of the ICJ ruling. I lived through the US war against Vietnam, a crime of genocide by the US itself, led by the Democratic Party, poisoning both the people and the land with Agent Orange, causing a huge number of birth defects and deaths for decades afterwards. I spent five years opposing that war and was pushed out of graduate school because of it, yet I remained a member of the Democratic Party. A mistake — oh yes — but not this time, not again. This time, I believe both Biden and Trump must be stopped. There is a close connection between the different forms of US dominance they each support — the one seeks to destroy democracy inside the US to gain power, the other supports continuing US dominance of the world through military and economic power. Both can count on Israel’s support. Neither seems to care who else gets hurt in the process. But this time, the US, the UK and the European countries willing to skewer Palestine and UNRWA, will be complicit in genocide themselves. Thus, above all, I believe we must support the International Court of Justice, as this genocidal war is nowhere near being stopped.
The US & UK governments are supporting each other in validating their inhuman acts & policies and must be publicly shamed. Dont buy American or UK goods. A boycott must be implemented. Until now that policy has been called for against Israel but it needs to be called for against US & UK goods to.
To stop funding UNRWA is by definition classic collective punishment and In direct contravention of the rulings at the ICJ to stop any further Genocidal acts
Those responsible should be prosecuted
@ Doug
And the Israeli government’s also thumbing its nose at the ICJ’s ruling by:-
(a) not preventing or punishing its own ministers (and others) from inciting the removal of the Palestinian population from Gaza and their replacement by Jewish Israelis; and
(b) not preventing or punishing the Israelis blocking aid trucks’ access to the crossing points into Gaza
The UNRWA is blatantly under attack to divert attention from the ICJ ruling that the State of Israel seems to be waging a genocidal war against the indigenous people of the region. To stop the relief funding for the victims, without good reason and without proof, yet actually being done as a ploy to encourage the identified oppressor, is indeed deliberately nasty.
@ Marge Berer : 29th January 2024 at 21:39 :
Hi, Marge. I’d love to know who you – are – going to vote for. I’ve noticed the word ‘socialist’ being used more and more, by US citizens, on social media.
Of course, socialism means something different in the US, than it does in Europe, but it’s a start.
Is that something that interests you?