But did you condemn Hamas…
JVL Introduction
Palestinian politicians in Israel condemned the October 7th attack but have not condemned Hamas or accepted that it is a terrorist organisation. Here, Louis Haj explores the reasons for this and starts by saying that it is important to distinguish between three things: “condemning acts, defining an organisation and agreeing to its annihilation.”
This is a thoughtful and important contribution to the debate and has resonance outside Israel, of course. Who can forget, for example, at the beginning of the genocide the calls for Palestinian Ambassador Husam Zomlot being asked to condemn Hamas while no-one speaking in support of Israel was asked to condemn the acts that State was carrying out never mind to condemn the Israeli government.
Now when Palestinian citizens of Israel have voted in unprecedented numbers in the Knesset elections, understanding this issue may be even more important. As the writer says, understanding does not mean agreement but is surely essential.
This article was originally published by Medium (via The Palestine Project) on Fri 6 Nov 2026. Read the original here.
But did you condemn Hamas…
“Why do the leaders of the Palestinian-Arab community in Israel find it difficult to define Hamas as a terrorist organisation that must be annihilated?”
Loading article text…
HAMAS = IRA ?
How can we condemn Hamas “terrorism”?
The Palestine population is trapped in a network of oppression. Every Jewish household has guns in the bedroom, while Palestinian teenagers are shot dead by the IDF for throwing stones at Israeli tanks.
The answer is that we do condemn terrorism – the killing of civilians for political purposes. Israel has a very long record of this – but also that carried out by Hamas, which is not unlike the IRA in the 1970s and 80s, which was largely accepted by the radical left.
There must be no moral ambiguity on this crucial point.