Skip to content

A Palestinian perspective on – and frustration with – the film “NAZA”

JVL Introduction

Samah Sabawi is from Gaza and seeing the much acclaimed film NAZA was difficult and nauseating.  Here she questions the framing along with the important point others have made that Palestinians have been telling the same story, risking their lives to do so, for more than three years. We think it is an important film and the matter of fact way in which the 24 soldiers retell what they did, what the chain of command ordered and also allowed is chilling but insurprising. This needs to be heard; these people kinew what they were doing, knew they were killing large numbers of innocent people and yet how literally nauseating it is to see that the only way to get this information is to protect the identities of the perpetrators, while Palestinians have been killed in their tens of thousands.

Sabawi agrees that the film is well made but questios whether it justifies the anonymity of those interviewed.  She also wishes that Yuval Abraham had asked them about motivation, about Zionism and Jewish supremacy and how the ideology has shaped the Jewish Israeli psyche such that they see Palestinian freedom as an existential threat and that this results in deaths and destruction for Palestinians.

We note that the film has been called a Blood libel by Israeli leaders who have not even seen the film. We wonder also why they object to us learning that the killing was done in this clinical, dehumanised and dehumanising way when their own genocidal rhetoric and orders called for this.

This article was originally published by Electronic Intifada on Thu 29 Oct 2026. Read the original here.

I’m from Gaza. NAZA made me scream.

Loading article text…

  • Samah, I ‘m sure the IDF interviewees couldn’t have been coaxed into taking part in NAZA unless their identities were protected. Apart from the risk of retaliation by the IDF and Israeli government, they were admitting to war crimes likely to put them in prison for decades.

    I’d argue not identifying the interviewees is a price worth paying. NAZA is the best “tool” we’ve got to educate and convince a world that STILL knows very little of the evil of Israel’s behaviour and the distortion of (sadly, most) Jewish Israelis’ moral sense. It completely destroys Israel’s propaganda about its “war” against Hamas. It proves this is Israel’s revenge and extermination project against defenceless Palestinians (21st century weapons of AI and bunker bombs replacing the Nazis’ locked trains to the gas ovens).

    The sheer horror of what NAZA shows, simply explained visually and in quiet conversation, hits home on all levels. Sophisticated French cinema audiences, US movie-goers and me and my friends have been stunned into silence by it. Hopefully NAZA will persuade everyone who’s seen it to work harder to stop Hell being visited on the Palestinians and to end Israel’s impunity.

    5
    0
  • I find this article puzzling. Of course, it is nauseating that the identities of the perpetrators are protected to save them from going to jail for speaking out. But it is hardly surprising that the perpetrators, people capable of committing unspeakable atrocities, should want to avoid jail by concealing their identities. They would be unlikely to be brave people ready to go to jail for speaking the truth. If they had been, they would have been unlikely to have committed the atrocities in the first place. The article also seems to be implicitly blaming the producers of the film for not revealing the perpetrators’ identities. But clearly the perpetrators only agreed to speak on condition of anonymity. What were the filmmakers supposed to do? Agree to the conditions and make the film, or not make the film at all, because they couldn’t agree to keep the identities secret? If they had agreed to the conditions and then revealed the identities anyway, would any Israel soldier in future speak to any filmmaker? I also disagree with the view of the author of the article that the film should have focused on Zionist ideology. Surely what matters is what the soldiers actually did. The underlying viewpoint of this article seems to me to be too similar to the ideological purity of the misguided (in my view) Greens’ Zionism is Racism motion.

    2
    1
  • https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/nov/12/gaza-benjamin-netanyahu-israel-opposition-palestinians
    Every child, every baby in Gaza is the enemy.” In a normal society, a politician who said something so depraved would face total reputational ruin. Not so in Israel…. Netanyahu’s bloc still won more votes than the Jewish-led opposition, despite his government’s failures over 7 October, his corruption trial, the cost of living crisis, the Iran war debacle, the controversy over exemptions from military service for ultra-Orthodox Jews and his assault on the judiciary…. According to polling last year, nearly eight in 10 Jewish Israelis agreed with the statement that “there are no innocent people in Gaza”.

    Then there is Nissim Vaturi, a member of Netanyahu’s Likud party who is deputy speaker of the Knesset. In January 2025, he declared: “Gaza is full of terrorists and every child born there is already a terrorist, from the moment of his birth.” Beyond wicked, yes, but how different is the attitude of Meirav Ben-Ari, a politician belonging to Lapid’s centrist party, when she exclaimed: “The children of Gaza have brought this upon themselves”?… [Eisenkot] is an Israeli general who spent months in Netanyahu’s war cabinet as it erased Gaza… He is also closely associated with the Dahiya doctrine, which emerged from Israel’s devastating 2006 invasion of Lebanon. In 2008, he threatened to use “disproportionate force” against the Lebanese villages from which Israel was attacked, insisting that these were “not civilian villages” but “military bases”

    when Ben-Gvir declared on 8 October that in response it was ‘legitimate’ to ‘go berserk’ his call was heeded not just by the military but also by Israeli civil society. Israel has been ‘going berserk’ ever since. I full cry. When Hamas killed over a thousand Jews, Israel as one body felt not only outraged but defiled, sullied by inferior members of the human race. It is misleading, a misnomer, to say that Jews have ‘dehumanised’ Palestinians …

    [cut to our limit of 300 words – admin]

    0
    0
  • It should come as no surprise there is already a copycat spoof video of Israeli propaganda on YouTube called “Naza: The Real Story”.

    1
    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.