Skip to content

Anti-Zionism: the wheel has turned full circle

JVL Introduction

We posted a review of Ben Moser’s new book here in Anti-Zionism has an important Jewish history.

In this article, Jeremy Salt looks at  a variety of responses Moser’s book has received, particularly its dismissal by both ‘extreme’ and  ‘liberal’ Zionists.

None shows more clearly how it has got under the skin than the description of the book by Simon Schama as “bizarre and repellent.” But then for him the Gaza genocide is simply a “monstrous libel.”

But as Salt show, anti-Zionism was the dominant response of Jews for a very long time.

“[T]he idea of establishing a Jewish state in a land that was not Jewish but largely Muslim would have remained the pipe dream of a fantasist but for British intervention.”

At the time, Jews knew this and

“rejected Zionism for practical, humanistic and theological reasons. The wheel has now turned almost full circle and in increasing numbers, Jews are rejecting it again.”

This article was originally published by the Palestine Chronicle on Wed 4 Nov 2026. Read the original here.

Uncovering the roots of Jewish anti-Zionism: the wheel of history is turning full circle

Loading article text…

  • Schama ….there you have the generalist european reinventing history in their own image contrary to the evidence.
    Supporters of zionism use the same old tools for their arguments – holocaust, persecution…what about the rest of the historical persecuted world and holacausts that have largely been forgotten to hold up German holocaust as a golden crown of the’ worst in all history’. The monopolising of trauma by zionists is vile.
    Print capitalism allows zionism ideology but suffocates opposition to it.
    Zionism is as rotten as racism, fascism, nazism etc. It is preposterous that one group of people have a right to ‘self determination’ over others. What is self determination but choices? And we all have choices. Let us stop wrapping ‘self determination’ and ‘persecution up in expensive wrapping paper for Israel.
    There should not be any special groups or religions over others.
    Zionism like measles is itching its way through religion, politics and dictating a corrupting form of what judaism should be and it is ensuring opposition is met with persecution?
    ‘It is incumbent upon every Jew to emulate Chananya, Mishael and Azariah and publicly announce even at the risk of his life that he is not part of this false Israel. He is a Jew and not a Zionist. He has no connection with these Zionist heretics or with their heretical leadership of the state.’ Rabbi Amram Blau

    4
    0
  • Simon Schama and others like him live in a deranged bubble that has nurtured them well – so far.

    1
    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.