Skip to content

Why are Anti-Zionist Jews creating new places to pray?

JVL Introduction

The established Jewish institutions have become so entwined with (virtually) uncritical support for Israel, even in the midst of a genocide and ethnic cleansing that many Jews who want justice and freedom for Palestinians are turning away from those synagogues and establishing new communities within which to practise their Judaism.

The phenomenon is, unsurprisingly most marked in the USA since this has the largest Jewish population outside Israel but we are seeing signs in the UK as well with new communities coming together in Brighton and Newcastle to observe Shabbat and the Jewish festivals. Others are framing some of their activism around Jewish rituals, eg many areas have opportunities to share a Shabbat and last year in Hastings and this year in Manchester local Jewish Groups for Palestine have sukkahs on the street; many local groups have hosted Passover Seders and much more.

As well as this fascinating article, I would recommend this video “Why so many American Jews are turning away from Israel“, which includes a non zionist Shabbat service too. (The video was made by the Guardian with Matthew Cassel, Tom Silverstone and Katie Arnold). Matthew Cassel has made other and powerful videos for the Guardian, eg interviewing settlers and Palestinians.

This article was originally published by Ha'aretz on Sun 20 Sep 2026. Read the original here.

Anti-Zionist Jewish Prayer Groups Are Growing. Now Comes the Hard Part

From Westchester, New York to Tucson, Arizona, anti-Zionist minyanim have been growing in the wake of the Gaza war. As they seek permanent locations, securing funds has proven elusive

Loading article text…

  • Maybe a helpful idea about finding AFFORDABLE accommodation with different sized rooms, often central, with kitchen facilities and car-parking?

    My own Quaker Meeting House has shared its accommodation with a Jewish community when it didn’t have its own synagogue … and this relationship between us still continues intermittently (eg when our flooring needed safety work done on it, the synagogue kindly let us meet in their building for 3 weeks).

    I’d expect other Quaker Meeting Houses in the UK and US to be equally welcoming to any Jewish group that needed somewhere “religiously neutral” to meet. Many of the religious and human values held by members of the new groups are shared by Quakers.

    0
    0
  • Alternative sites of worship might actually help make non-Zionist and anti-Zionist Jews more safe. It might also provide clarity and help differentiate between revenge attackers and those who hate Judaism & Jews. The St George Cross used to be a dormant largely abandoned piece iconography – resented by conquered Scots, Welsh and Irish, who were fire-bombing English holiday homes in the post era and equally despised by those who remembered the Crusades and the British Empire (the 1966 England football team campaigned under the Union Jack). These days waving the Israeli flag in public has similar effect, something in part predicted by Professor JK Galbraith back in 70s. The Heaton Moor synagogue has a photo gallery of members doing just this and supporting Israel during the Genocide in a city – Manchester – that had been staging anti-Genocide protests across its major road junctions, all during this period. That is NOT to say attacks on Heaton Moor and those like them should be supported or encouraged. But given the historical precedents, alternatives to Zionist supporting places of worship are logical. For Prof Galbraith see – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3v6GMCQ7Tw4 If this link for Heaton Moor Synagogue works correctly just keep scrolling right wards – https://www.hphc.org.uk/templates/photogallery_cdo/aid/4074122/jewish/Photo-Gallery.htm#photoid=12942739

    3
    2

Comments are now closed.