Skip to content

Jewish anti-Zionism in the UK: a historic overview

JVL Introduction

The Jewish Bloc ran a dayschool on Anti-Zionism and the Jewish Left in London on 18th May 2025.

Joseph Finlay contributed a valuable survey of the history of Jewish anti-Zionist ideas and movements in the UK and published a lightly edited version on his Torat Albion blog which we repost here.

RK

This article was originally published by Torat Albion on Wed 21 May 2025. Read the original here.

Jewish anti-Zionism in the UK: a historic overview

Loading article text…

  • Here’s a great quote from George Steiner, thank you Joseph for sending the link!
    ‘The notion that the appalling road of Jewish life and the ever-renewed miracle of survival should have as their end, as their justification, the setting up of a small nation-state in the Middle East, crushed by military burdens, petty and even corrupt in its politics, shrill in its parochialism, is implausible.
    ‘I cannot shake off the conviction that the torment and the mystery of resilience in Judaism exemplify, enact, an arduous truth: that human beings must learn to be each other’s guests on this small planet, even as they must learn to be guests of being itself and of the natural world. This is a truth humbly immediate, to our breath, to our skin, to the passing shadow we cast on a ground inconceivably more ancient than our visitation, and it is also a terribly abstract, morally and psychologically exigent truth. Man will have to learn it or he will be made extinct in suicidal waste and violence.
    ‘The State of Israel is an endeavour – wholly understandable, in many aspects admirable, perhaps historically inescapable – to normalize the condition, the meaning of Judaism. It would make the Jew level with the common denominator of modern ‘belonging’. It is, at the same time, an attempt to eradicate the deeper truth of unhousedness, of an at-homeness in the word, which are the legacy of the Prophets and of the keepers of the text.’
    Great words for diasporists.
    Actually Joseph I think you underestimate antizionism in the Jewsh Socialist Group (which certainly attracted me to the group, more than Bundism; in fact the Hackney Alternative Jewish Alliance was formed around people with a more Central-European assimilated heritage). Contrastingly ,I also wonder if maybe you underestimate the strength of pre-war Zionism. Emmanuel LItvinoff and my late father-in-law both came from different parts of East London and were both members of the young blue-and-whites. This evidence is only anecdotal and literary of course, you may have the figures. Anyway many thanks

    0
    0
  • Amanda – I have not heard of Hackney Alternative Jewish Alliance! Please tell me more – when, what, who

    0
    0

Comments are now closed.