Skip to content

Compare and Contrast – defining antisemitism and Islamophobia

JVL Introduction

How antisemitism is defined has been a key issue for JVL since our founding meeting in 2017. The launch event was addressed by then QC Sir Stephen Sedley, a Jewish jurist of distinction. Warning against adoption of the IHRA working definition, he highlighted “the implications of a rulebook or a culture which proscribes all but respectful criticism of Israel.”

Since then, that particular rule book/ culture has been hailed by an alarming number of establishment institutions as a necessary tool in the fight against antisemitism. Has its adoption led to a reduction in hostility towards Jews in the UK? Most certainly not, and this editor seriously doubts the efficacy of such codes in combatting any form of race hate. But the drive to impose the IHRA WD, allegedly on behalf of Jews, has understandably prompted members of other communities to campaign for equivalent definitions.

The article below from The New Arab sets out the conclusions of a critique by CAGE International of  the UK Government’s “Anti-Muslim Hostility” Definition. Titled Disingenuous, Double Standards, And The Normalisation Of Islamophobia, it traces the glaring contrast between the definitions offered to  Jewish and Muslim communities.

“One widens what the state can police, extending suspicion to criticism of a foreign government whose wars Britain supports. The other narrows what the state can be held responsible for, so that its own role in producing Islamophobia falls outside the frame.”

The dichotomy is evident in much recent government policy making, including the reports by Lord Mann and Sir David Bell which target the expression of sympathy for Palestine within UK health and education services respectively. Much more needs to be done to unite campaigns against such dangerous developments.

 

This article was originally published by The New Arab on Thu 12 Nov 2026. Read the original here.

Britain’s hypocrisy on Islamophobia and antisemitism won't protect anyone

The British government’s contrasting definitions of Islamophobia and antisemitism reveal whose safety it prioritises, explains Karsen Breanne.

Loading article text…

No comments on this post so far.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.