Skip to content

Cruelty and hypocrisy at heart of Mahmood’s ‘earned settlement’ plan

JVL Introduction

Listening to media reports of Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood’s plans for migrants seeking leave to remain in the UK, you’d think she was generously open wide the portals to reward people who have earned the right to settle in this country.

Not so, as explained in this Tribune article by Michael Boyle, director of a charity supporting migrants who have no recourse to public funds (NRPF).

News stories focusing on a partial U-turn that exempts migrant care workers from a proposed fifteen year wait to settle, obscure the cruelty of what is actually being planned – “a major intensification of the hostile environment [that] targets nearly every person in the immigration system”.

Boyle says the proposals reveal total hypocrisy at the core of Andy Burnham’s government.

As mayor of Greater Manchester in 2023, Burnham wrote to Suella Braverman, then home secretary, highlighting “the incoherence between commitments to end rough sleeping and current asylum and immigration policies that drive homelessness”, and called on her to “end NRPF in order to end rough sleeping.”

“Barely three months into his premiership, he’s signed off on a policy that will deliver the exact the opposite of these promises,” Boyle writes.

For a detailed briefing on the government’s plans see https://righttoremain.org.uk/earnedsettlement/

 

This article was originally published by Tribune on Thu 12 Nov 2026. Read the original here.

‘Earned Settlement’ Is a Vicious Attack on Migrants

Behind the government’s talk of ‘fairness’ is a major intensification of the hostile environment.

Loading article text…

  • According to my point any one granted 5 years refugee status before 2 March 2026 or who applied assylum before 2 March 2026 should be under the traditional 5 years route as told by the home secretary earlier as a persecuted non Muslim minded person I am disowned by my family bullied by neighbors beaten by our corrupt politicians and police in bangladesh were I never cannot go back as they gave my Refugee status 5 years and it’s written I can be able to apply for ilr after that now sabana Mahmood home secretary is acting hypocritical way breaking promises retrorespectively

    0
    0
  • She is just a puppet. No Integrity. They crave power and ignorer to keep it when they have it they will say anything. How so many of them managed to keep their jobs when Starmer was kicked out is simply because they backed Burnham who in turn quid pro quo kept them in a Labour Government- they stand for nothing.
    Immigration is like the new colonised industry. She is just the puppet and her puppet masters tell her what to say and do.
    Immigration is not the problem but politics and this extreme view that some people have less value because they come on a boat. If the UK did not interfere with other countries and their history of colonial rule these places would not be as poor as they are and their people seeking a better life in the countries that made them worse off in there own.
    Immigration is not the problem. Politics is ugly and extreme and politicians are just puppets for the money people who control them.

    0
    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.