Skip to content

The Zionist left never stood in the way of transfer

JVL Introduction

Hagai El-Ad, Israeli journalist and director general of Israel’s premier human-rights organisation, B’Tselem, for a decade from 2013,  writes about the idea of “transfer” in Zionism and the Zionist left’s intransigent opposition to it in the nineties.

That was then.

Now he predicts, in the face of threats of expelling “the Arabs”, called euphemistically “voluntary emigration”, it won’t do anything to stop it.

El-ad points out that Zionist left’s actions over the years, (“our” actions, as he writes as part of the left), speak loud and clear, that the intransigence was always phoney. Just look at 1948 and 1967.

And he asks, as preparations for expulsion from Gaza City are being finalised: “Is there really any doubt that we won’t lie under the wheels of the trucks, but rather drive them?”

RK

This article was originally published by Haaretz on Sun 24 Aug 2025. Read the original here.

The Zionist left never stood in the way of transfer

35 years ago, Amos Oz and Yossi Sarid promised to fight the expulsion of Arabs. Yet the Zionist left instead of standing in the way of transfer executed it

Loading article text…

Comments are now closed.