A meticulous account of Zionist terror
JVL Introduction
When author, activist and musician Thomas Suárez published his first book about Zionist terrorism, State of Terror, in 2017, he was subjected to a vicious campaign of abuse which led to the cancellation of events at which he was due to speak. The Jewish Chronicle reported outrage from the Board of Deputies of British Jews in an article headed Board halt Israel hate author talk -Leader praises Quakers after they cancel Palestine campaign group event with State of Terror author. This led to a public statement by the Cambridge Quakers correcting the Board of Deputies’ spin on what had happened, and also a rare reprimand from the Independent Press Standards Organisation IPSO after Suárez complained. The paper had given “a significantly misleading impression of the complainant’s expressed views, on an extremely sensitive subject.”
Suárez’s book, Palestine Hijacked, returns to that “extremely sensitive subject”. We publish below a review in which Graham Bash calls it an “excellent, must read”.
Bash commends it as “a meticulous and painstaking account of how Zionist terror was central to the period under the British Mandate, central to the creation of the Israeli state and central also to its subsequent expansions covering the whole of Mandate Palestine and beyond.”
He notes that in cataloguing Israel’s crimes, Suárez reminds us of one of its most heinous – its hijacking of Jewish identity.
To order this book go to https://palestinehijacked.net
Palestine Hijacked by Thomas Suarez – How the state of Israel was created by Zionist terrorism
A review by Graham Bash, JVL Political Officer
A few weeks back JVL published an article from New Arab dated 2nd November showing that “newly examined British intelligence documents reveal how officials warned that Zionist militants were using terrorism to establish a Jewish state in Palestine.”
This information has in fact been known for years. It was contained In Ilan Pappe’s The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine and in two books by Thomas Suárez, firstly State Of Terror, How Terrorism Created Modern Israel, 2016 and then a revised, updated version, Palestine Hijacked, How Zionism Forged An Apartheid State From River To Sea, 2022, the latter reviewed here.
It is a meticulous and painstaking account of how Zionist terror was central to the period under the British Mandate, central to the creation of the Israeli state and central also to its subsequent expansions covering the whole of Mandate Palestine and beyond. At times the sheer volume of information detailing the acts of terror can be ‘tedious’, to quote the author himself.
But the effort of ploughing through this catalogue of terror is so worthwhile because Suárez answers the argument that another form of Zionism was possible. It was not and is not. Any alternative Zionism, such as cultural Zionism which did not insist on a state for the Jews, was only ever marginal and largely disappeared a century ago.
Zionist terrorism and ethnic cleansing of Palestine was central to the whole project of building a colonial settler state – based on the displacement and elimination of the indigenous people of Palestine. The recent genocide in Gaza, and settler violence in the West Bank supported by the Israeli state, are but the latest episodes. They are the logical outcome of what mainstream Zionism has always been. Have no illusions that it will be much different if/when Netanyahu is overthrown.
The message of Palestine Hijacked is clear from almost the first words of the introduction: “The prevailing narrative of Israel-Palestine is of a complex, even irreconcilable, conflict between ancient enemies. What history and ongoing reality expose is however something vastly simpler; the single story of a racial-nationalist settler movement – Zionism – determined to ethnically cleanse a land for itself …. settler-colonialism wrapped in elaborate mythology.” (As Labour Zionist leader and Israel’s first Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion put it, the Bible was their mandate to take Palestine.)
And: “Zionist leaders across the spectrum, from the allegedly ‘moderate’ Chaim Weizmann to terrorist leaders like Menachem Begin and Yitzhak Shamir, uniformly demanded Jewish supremacy in Palestine and denounced any suggestion of non-Jews’ participation in democracy.”
Suárez argues – and proves – that though the extreme right militias, Irgun and Stern Gang (Lehi), were prominent in the ethnic cleansing, “the Jewish Agency’s Haganah was little different, and by early 1948 this official militia – soon to be the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) –terrorised the non-Jewish population with barbaric depopulation campaigns that surpassed the abilities of the Irgun or Lehi.”
He writes too of Palestinian resistance, echoing James Baldwin’s famous words that “people who have been wronged will attempt to right the wrong; they would not be people if they didn’t. They can rarely afford to be scrupulous about the means they will use. They will use such means as come to hand.” Suárez says of the Palestinians: “Any people attacked, will resist in extreme ways, especially when denied any means of self defence….. as the critical years 1940-1947 will illustrate, the virtual absence of Palestinian violent resistance changed nothing.”
This book explains how the partitioning of Palestine was “a capitulation to Zionist terror”. The British and the UN knew in advance that the partition was for the Zionists simply a “temporary expedient” (as the British put it), that the Zionists were using partition as a tactic. By the time of the ceasefire at the end of 1948, Israel had seized and ethnically cleansed not just the 56.5% of Mandate Palestine that the United Nations had designated for the Israeli state, but also half of the Palestinians’ portion.
But Israeli statehood was by no means the end of Zionist terror. On the contrary, it was a means of accelerating it. Israeli state terror reached its depth of depravity (so far) with the genocide in Gaza – the totally logical outcome of all that preceded it.
The author also explains that Zionism is what it is because of its relationship to world imperialism, particularly British, then US imperialism. That was and is a relationship central to the whole history of Zionism.
This excellent, must read, book explains how we have got to where we are today. Suárez concludes by explaining that: “Ethnic cleansing, apartheid, and the acquisition of territory by force are not disagreements to be mediated. They are crimes to be stopped.” And he finally reminds us of one of Israel’s greatest crimes – its hijacking of Jewish identity.
Order the book at https://palestinehijacked.net
I’d like to echo Graham’s comments. Tom Suarez is one of the most scrupulous and thorough anti-Zionist researchers there are. His area of study, the Mandate period and the terror that the Zionists used to gain supremacy, one of the most under researched. I highly recommend the book.
I remember how Portsmouth Council and the Prevent officers colluded to prevent a local community hall from staging a meeting with Tom organised by Portsmouth PSC. The mere fact that the Zionists felt so threatened by someone who was a researcher demonstrates how much they have to hide about their ghastly settler colonial project