On Westminster Council’s attempted whitewashing of Zionism
JVL Introduction
Westminster’s councillors have joined together to submit a cross-party “Zionism is not Racism” motion. It will be heard at a council meeting this coming week.
There are 32 Tory Councillors and 22 Labour in Westminster. There is no Green councillor to speak out against this travesty-of-the-truth motion.
Affirming that Zionism is not racism is utterly preposterous, flying in the face of Zionist deeds and Zionism’s own pronouncements over the last century and a half.
We are expected to agree that whiter-than-white Zionism never hurt a flea, never had a racist bone in its body: that its state never expelled a Palestinian in the Nakba, discriminated against a Palestinian citizen (let alone has on its statute books over 60 laws which do precisely that), or killed a Palestinian – let alone 75,000 – in Gaza in the last three years, or dreamed of ethnically cleaning its illegally occupied territory.
Or that Zionism is the ideology of a state described by its own premier human-rights organisation B’Tselem, as an apartheid state, a state “of Jewish supremacy”.
All the waters of Westminster will fail to sweeten this petty politicking act.
Jonathan Rosenhead writes for JVL
On Westminster Council’s attempted whitewashing of Zionism
The ‘Zionism is not Racism’ motion (see full text below) being proposed at Westminster Council is opportunist, ill-informed and deliberately misleading. It centres the rights of Jews as if the treatment of the Palestinians by the explicitly Zionist state of Israel is an irrelevance. The Palestinians are not even mentioned in the motion – whereas the Green Party motion that it criticises was almost entirely about what Israel and Zionism has done to the Palestinians.
The elephant in the room, carefully avoided by the motion, is the mass killing of Palestinian civilians, the institutionalised torture, and the ethnic cleansing perpetrated by the Zionist state of Israel on Palestinians. Also missing is the history of discrimination against Palestinians since the foundation of the state of Israel, amounting now to apartheid. So too is Israel’s 2018 Basic Law which declared that the right to national self-determination in Israel belongs only to the Jewish people. In June a United Nations independent commission concluded that Israeli authorities and security forces have been committing genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes against the Palestinians.
During the IDF’s assault on Gaza Israel’s Israel’s Foreign Minister advocated for the halting of humanitarian aid to a starving people and the erasure of Palestine. Defence Minister Yoav Gallant stated on 9th October 2023, setting the terms of the impending assault on Gaza: “We are fighting human animals and we are acting accordingly”. That sounds like racism to us.
The motion states that “Zionism, in its most widely understood sense, is the belief that the Jewish people have the right to national self-determination in their historic homeland.” No, after three years of live-streamed genocide Zionism is now most widely understood as the foundational and dominant political ideology of Israel, the state which has committed and is still committing these atrocities. The proposers of this motion have put their telescopes to their blind eyes and in effect pronounced “I see no history, no torture, no apartheid, no ethnic cleansing, no genocide against the Palestinians”.
What then do the proposers of the motion think is the justification for Israel’s trashing of all the laws of war and humanitarian law? That it is necessary to uphold “the Jewish people’s right to self-determination”. Why is that policy racist? Because it excludes the at least equal right of the Palestinian people.
The motion makes two attempts at justifying why the Jewish people have a “right to self-determination” in the disputed land called both Israel and Palestine. The first is based on the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance ‘Working Definition of Antisemitism’. Never mind that the overwhelming consensus among (for example) international scholars, historians, and civil rights groups is that the IHRA working definition is a distorted and unreliable basis for demarcating what is antisemitic from what is deserved and essential criticism of a racist state.
The second attempted justification for the claim that only Jews have the right to self-determination on that small patch of land is the motion’s statement that Israel/Palestine is “the historic homeland” of the Jewish people. The tottering foundation of this claim seems to be that if a people once occupied a territory it remains theirs forever, regardless of who is living there now. Most historians believe that Jews ceased to be the largest population group in Palestine some time in the 3rd to 5th century CE. That was around the time that the Angles and Saxons, Germanic invaders, were taking over by force most of the British Isles from the indigenous Britons, who were driven to the margins or beyond. By the logic of this Westminster motion the Celts have an invincible claim to the whole of England.
The Westminster Tories’ motion is yet another attempt to present criticism of Israel as if it were criticism of Jews. Its purpose is to try to use the cry of “Antisemitism! Antisemitism!” to protect Israel. As Jews we are well aware that antisemitism is an ongoing concern, and one which needs to be countered. To attempt to redirect and repurpose that concern in order to defend Israel from the criticism it deserves is the height of cynicism.
Motions such as this one do not combat antisemitism. Rather they can in fact foster it through their claim for a special status for Jewish concerns. It is easy to see how this can amplify the erroneous and dangerous belief, now becoming more widespread, that Jews are given special protection because they exercise an undue influence on public affairs.
The text of the proposed Westminster Council motion
This Council notes that:
1) At its autumn conference in Brighton on 4 October 2026, the Green Party of England and Wales adopted a motion, by 1,022 votes to 813, declaring itself an ‘anti-Zionist party’ and stating that Zionism will be ‘treated as any other form of racism’.
2) Zionism, in its most widely understood sense, is the belief that the Jewish people have the right to national self-determination in their historic homeland. For a majority of British Jews, it forms part of their Jewish identity, although Jewish people hold a wide range of views about Zionism, the State of Israel and its government.
3) The Board of Deputies of British Jews and other Jewish community representatives have expressed serious concern about the motion, and four of the Green Party’s five MPs have publicly rejected it.
4) The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, adopted by this Council in June 2018, gives as an example of antisemitism ‘denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavour’.
This Council believes that:
1) Zionism is not racism. Support for the Jewish people’s right to self-determination is not racist, and Jewish people are entitled to the same right to national self-determination as any other people.
2) Criticism of the policies and actions of the Israeli Government is legitimate and is not antisemitic. But declaring Zionism to be racism goes far beyond such criticism: it brands most British Jews as racists because of a part of their identity, and risks leaving Jewish residents feeling unwelcome in public life.
3) The Green Party’s position is incompatible with the Council’s duty to foster good relations between communities and with the Members’ Code of Conduct.
4) Antisemitism must be challenged consistently, whichever political party or individual it comes from.
This Council therefore resolves to:
1) Affirm that Zionism is not racism, and reject the position, adopted by the Green Party at its October 2026 conference, that Zionism should be ‘treated as any other form of racism’.
2) Reaffirm its support for the Jewish residents of Westminster, its opposition to antisemitism in all its forms, and its continued commitment to the IHRA working definition of antisemitism.
3) Ask the Leader of the Council to write to local synagogues across Westminster and the London Jewish Forum to share this resolution and to offer reassurance to Jewish residents.
4) Ask the Standards Committee to review, within six months, the Council’s equality, diversity and community cohesion training and policies, to ensure that they are consistent with the IHRA working definition and do not treat Jewish residents’ support for Jewish self-determination as a form of racism.
Makes you wonder ….they can’t apologise or address historical slavery yet the uneducated can past motions on zionism not being racist.
How many have been funded by pro zionist lobby groups?
How many care to hear from the jewish community who do not support zionism.
If people continue to vote for these rodents we will continue to see the persecution of the innocent, the rise of semitic islamaphobia, racism and antisemitism against the jewish community who reject zionism.
This move by Westminster council to discuss “Zionism is not racism” will in fact serve to support the Green Party policy that Zionism is racism.
Since the founding of Israel, it has been protected by a solid wall of approval which was built on almost total ignorance of the reality of life under apartheid in Palestine-Israel.
The Israel-approving councillors in Westminster have walked into a trap. Zionism is a self-condemning ideology and only receives approval while the general population is unaware of its reality.
Whatever the outcome in the Council chamber, a very public debate will serve to inform people of this reality.