Israel’s Dangerous Philosophical Roots, from Jabotinsky to Netanyahu
JVL Introduction
Philosopher Martin Cohen best known for writing accessible books on philosophy has written a new book – Israel- Palestine and the Case for One State. In this article he turns his attention to the philosophies underlying the Zionist project from the earliest days – long before 1948. Force and expulsion were there from long ago as well as the “neccessity” to have an enemy and, indeed, antisemitic ideas. To this we can add Israel’s use of the Holocaust so that they are the permanent victims which allows them to tell themselves – and the rest of the world – that everything they do is done in self defence. There is much here about Jabotinsky including fascist influence on him and his disdain for what he termed “the ugly Yid” in comparison with the Hebrews who would run the new country. There is also reference to Herzl and Nazi Jurist Carl Shmitt.
Jabotinsky continues to impact Israel today, not least because of his heavy influence on Likud but, argues Cohen, what is happening now is far more extreme than anything even Jabotinsky would have endorsed. He believes that the country is at fundamental odds from humanitarian and international values and the charter of the UN that enabled Israel to come into being. He says that Israel “…is racist because of its fundamental constitution and practical policies. Land is designated as Jewish, housing is reserved for Jews, crucially, citizenship is reserved for Jews… Jews living in the Occupied Territories have the vote – but Palestinians do not.”
This article was originally published by Palestine Chronicle on Tue 10 Nov 2026. Read the original here.
Israel’s Dangerous Philosophical Roots, from Jabotinsky to Netanyahu
Like Jabotinsky, Israelis are convinced that their security and interests are best served not by democratic values, far less by consensus, but only by military force.
Loading article text…
Fascinating piece, which makes me want to get hold of his book. His comments on the nebulous nature of Zionism and the distraction and division that have been created by the Green Party’s “Zionism is Racism” motion seem to me to be spot on:
“Political debate still swirls around the true nature of Zionism. It is a meaningless term, a philosophical jargon that means many different things from an airy-fairy story of a hill in Palestine to the military plans of Jabotinsky. In the UK, the ruling Labour Party has just severed links with the Green Party over a motion passed by the Greens that “Zionism is racism”. How the supporters of genocide must cluck with pleasure as two varieties of its British critics fall out over a word! The arguments so conveniently hide the reality and important fact that Israeli policy is racist, to use a term that seems totally inadequate to sum up the barely disguised horror of everyday reality.”
Let me declare an interest. Martin Cohen commissioned me to write the section on Zionism for Hodder & Stoughton’s ‘Essentials of Philosophy & Ethics’ which he edited. Nonetheless this is a muddled piece.
The Oslo Accords did not create the Palestinian Authority ‘as part of the pathway’ to two states. Quite the contrary, Oslo enabled the settlements to continue to expand and transformed the Palestinians into their own policemen. It was the biggest disaster since the Nakba.
Martin says that ‘citizenship is reserved for Jews’. In Israel itself this is not true but citizenship is so devalued for Palestinians that it is meaningless.
It is not only Palestinians in the occupied territories but all Palestinians who are banned from converting to Judaism. Judaism is now a religion based on an artificial ethnicity.
There is much to commend itself in the above essay but Martin is wrong when he says that Zionism ‘is a meaningless term’. He says that ‘Israel is not racist because it is Zionist; it is racist because of its fundamental constitution and practical policies.’
This is tautological. A circular argument. Why is Israel and its constitution and policies racist? Because its guiding ideology and the movement that brought it into existence are Zionist.
When Netanyahu and Eisenkot say they will form a Zionist government they mean keeping the Arabs out. Zionism was the identity that settler colonialism took in Palestine.
Judaism became the marker that defined the herrenvolk. Though not being a religious doctrine itself. Zionism dictated the doctrines of Hebrew Land, Labour and Produce that was realised in the Apartheid state we see today.
Martin says that Zionism ‘means many different things’. I disagree. Zionism means what is happening to Palestinians not what is in the head of fragrant Jewish adolescents.
Deborah Maccoby’s argument against the Green Party’s Zionism is Racism policy is puzzling. She says
‘the ruling Labour Party has just severed links with the Green Party over a motion passed by the Greens that “Zionism is racism”. How the supporters of genocide must cluck with pleasure as two varieties of its British critics fall out over a word!’
Since when is the ruling Labour Party and the Labour Government a critic of the genocide? It is supplying the arms for that genocide!
If I am reading the Russian correctly by Jabotinsky (The Iron Wall. Colonisation of Palestine. Agreement of Arabs impossible at present. Zionism must go forward. 04.11.1923)
He was fully aware it was colonising. -‘All natives resist colonists’ and the ideology was changing Palestine into ‘The Land of Israel’.
Equally he was also aware there is a difference between Judaism and Zionism – ‘In the first place, if anyone objects that this point of view is immoral, It is not true: either Zionism is moral and just ,or it is immoral and unjust.But that is a question that we should have settled before we became Zionists. If you ‘become’ it wasn’t a ‘was’.. He argues quite well for modern zionism as a new ideology with no mention of Judaism. He clearly does not call himself a jew but a zionist. And there clearly lies the distinction.